← Back to blog

Unit Economics Verification: Testing Reported Metrics Against Public Filings

November 15, 2026
Unit Economics Verification: Testing Reported Metrics Against Public Filings

Unit economics verification is the practice of reconstructing a company's per-customer or per-order profitability from public records, then testing whether the ratio the company reports (LTV/CAC, payback, contribution margin) can be reproduced from its own filings. A reported ratio is a claim. The verification question is whether the numerator, the denominator, the cohort and the time horizon behind it are disclosed well enough for an outside reader to rebuild it, and whether the rebuilt figure matches the narrative.

The sections below set out what the metrics measure, what public filings and SEC staff correspondence show about their disclosure, how cost completeness is tested, a worked case study that can be reproduced from a shareholder letter, and a repeatable procedure for institutional investors, governance advocates, journalists, regulators and proxy advisors.

Lacunaindex
Test Corporate Claims Against Public Evidence
Lacuna Index evaluates how public companies deliver on their claims using disclosures, filings, and other publicly available records.
Visit

TL;DR

  • Unit economics are only verifiable when the filing defines the economic unit, the cohort, the cost pool and the horizon; a ratio without those four is a narrative claim, not a measurement.
  • The most reliable public check is arithmetic reconstruction: for example, eHealth's Q1 2026 slides disclose both inputs and the formula, so the stated ratio can be recomputed.
  • SEC staff comment letters show where reported LTV/CAC ratios are most often challenged: non-GAAP construction, missing cohort detail and unreconciled calculations.
  • Cost completeness depends on accounting treatment: under ASC 340-40, incremental costs of obtaining a contract can be capitalized, which changes what appears in reported expense.
  • A strong LTV/CAC ratio and a long payback can coexist, so both must be read together with the cost of capital.

Table of Contents

What unit economics measure, and what counts as the economic unit

Unit economics describe the revenue and cost attached to one repeatable unit of the business, so that profitability can be assessed before fixed overhead and growth spending obscure it. The unit is a management choice, not a fact of nature: a subscription company may use the customer or the account, a marketplace the order, a retailer the store, an insurer the policy. Each choice changes every downstream metric.

Three questions fix the unit before any ratio is read:

  1. What is counted as one unit? A paying account, a seat, a covered life, a shipped order. Definitions that change between periods make ratios non-comparable.
  2. Which revenues and costs attach to it? Gross margin, variable fulfillment, servicing, payment processing and support are candidates. Whether they are included defines the difference between gross margin and contribution margin.
  3. Over what window is it measured? A first-order margin, a twelve-month cohort and a lifetime estimate answer different questions, and a lifetime estimate depends on a retention assumption the company controls.

For an outside analyst, the practical consequence is that unit economics are almost never reported on a standardized basis. Unlike revenue or operating income, no single accounting standard governs LTV or CAC. The reported figure is a management metric, and verification consists of establishing how it was built.

The four metrics and what each one can and cannot show

Four measures carry most of the weight in unit economics disclosure. Each answers a different question, and none is sufficient alone.

MetricWhat it measuresPrincipal verification risk
Customer acquisition cost (CAC)Sales and marketing spend attributable to winning one new unitCost pool definition: which spend is included, and whether expansion or retention spend is mixed in
Lifetime value (LTV)Expected cumulative margin from a unit over its lifeRetention and margin assumptions; whether the figure is constrained, discounted or cohort-observed
Contribution marginRevenue less variable costs per unitAllocation of shared costs between variable and fixed categories
Payback periodTime for cumulative margin to recover CACWhether margin or revenue is used, and whether the cohort is observed or projected

The ratio of LTV to CAC indicates whether a unit creates value; payback indicates how long capital is committed before it does. A company can therefore present an attractive ratio while carrying a heavy financing burden, which is why the two must be read together.

Lemonade's Q2 2023 shareholder letter, filed with the SEC, illustrates the tension directly. The company disclosed that its direct-to-consumer model front-loads costs, requiring all of CAC to be financed upfront with payback typically around 24 months. A favorable lifetime ratio does not remove that capital requirement. The pace at which a company can grow is set by its cost of capital against the cash-flow gap, not by the ratio alone.

What public disclosures actually contain

The verification method depends on how much the filer reveals. Disclosure falls along a spectrum, from fully reconstructable to opaque.

Reconstructable disclosure: the eHealth example

eHealth's Q1 2026 earnings slides, filed with the SEC, state the inputs and the formula. The company reported a Medicare LTV-to-CAC ratio of 1.4x, up from 1.2x in Q1 2025, with Medicare Advantage LTV of $938 (up 3% year over year) and total acquisition cost per MA-equivalent approved member of $676 (down 10% year over year). The ratio is defined as constrained lifetime value of commissions per MA-equivalent approved member divided by total acquisition cost, which includes customer care, enrollment and variable marketing costs.

This is the standard a verifier looks for, because the stated ratio can be recomputed in one line: $938 divided by $676 is approximately 1.39, consistent with the reported 1.4x. The same disclosure also allows the analyst to ask better questions. Which cost lines sit inside the acquisition cost? What does "constrained" mean for the lifetime value of commissions, and how has the constraint moved? Does the improvement in the ratio come from the numerator (up 3%) or the denominator (down 10%)? In this case the denominator carried most of the change, which directs attention to cost classification and the efficiency claim behind it.

eHealth Medicare LTV and CAC ratio calculation

Partially disclosed: what SEC staff ask for

Where companies publish a ratio without its components, SEC staff correspondence records the questions a verifier would otherwise have to ask alone. Three published exchanges are instructive. A fuller method for reading this correspondence appears in the five-step traceable SEC comment letter analysis.

Chewy, 2019. In May 2019 correspondence, the SEC staff asked the company to address Item 10(e) of Regulation S-K for its LTV-to-CAC ratios, noting that LTV was computed from cumulative contribution profit, a non-GAAP income measure. Chewy responded that the underlying cohort contribution profits were not material for separate disclosure and could not be reconciled in any meaningful way. The exchange establishes the central point: when LTV is built from a non-GAAP profit measure, the staff treats the ratio as subject to non-GAAP presentation rules, and the company may decline to reconcile it.

ODDITY Tech, 2022. In a May 2022 comment letter on a draft Form F-1, the staff asked the company to present separate LTV and CAC calculations for new U.S. customers acquired during 2020, or remove the LTV:CAC ratio. The request targets the cohort: a blended ratio across geographies and vintages can mask the economics of the newest customers.

A 2021 registrant. In a July 2021 comment letter, the staff asked a registrant to disclose the underlying calculations supporting its five-year LTV/CAC ratio of over 5x. The company declined, arguing the components were commercially sensitive because competitors could reverse-engineer its pricing and media-buying strategy. The response shows the structural limit of public verification: the more a company treats the inputs as competitive secrets, the more the ratio rests on trust.

The pattern across the three is consistent. Staff attention concentrates on non-GAAP construction, cohort specificity and the availability of calculations. Those are the same three properties a verifier tests.

Partially disclosed: what SEC staff ask for

Contract-level disclosure

Revenue is the one input with a codified disclosure framework. FASB's materials state that the revenue disclosure requirements aim to enable users to understand the nature, amount, timing and uncertainty of revenue and cash flows from customer contracts, including disaggregated revenue, contract balances, remaining performance obligations and significant judgments. For the revenue side of unit economics, these disclosures give an audited anchor against which a company's per-unit revenue claim can be cross-checked, for example by comparing implied revenue per customer against disaggregated revenue and contract balances.

Testing the completeness of costs, attribution and assumptions

A ratio is only as reliable as its cost pool. Four tests apply.

Test 1: Does the cost pool reconcile to the income statement?

CAC should be traceable, directly or through a stated bridge, to reported sales and marketing expense. A gap between total reported sales and marketing and the spend used in CAC is not an error by itself, since some spend serves retention or expansion, but the gap must be explained. When the numerator of the ratio cannot be tied to a GAAP line, the reader is relying on management's allocation.

Test 2: Where does the accounting treatment place acquisition costs?

FASB's ASU 2014-09 (Topic 606 and Subtopic 340-40) creates the U.S. GAAP framework for revenue from contracts with customers and for capitalizing and amortizing the incremental costs of obtaining a contract, such as sales commissions. This determines whether a CAC-type cost appears as current expense or as a deferred asset amortized over time. An analyst computing CAC from the income statement alone may understate cash acquisition cost when commissions are capitalized. The cash flow statement and the footnote roll-forward of capitalized contract costs supply the missing amount.

The difficulty is not new. In a comment letter on the proposed standard, IBM argued that commission models often mix new-customer acquisition, expansion and relationship management, which makes the capitalization boundary hard to draw. For the verifier, the same mixing means that a company's CAC denominator may blend new-logo and expansion effort, and the filing may not separate them.

Test 3: Are the cohort and the horizon stated?

A blended, all-customer ratio can differ substantially from the ratio for the most recent cohort. The ODDITY request illustrates the correct standard: a defined cohort, a defined period, a separate calculation. A verifier should record, for every reported ratio, whether the cohort is observed or modeled, and how many periods of actual retention support the lifetime estimate.

Test 4: Are the adjustments consistent over time?

When LTV rests on a non-GAAP profit measure, the quality of the adjustments becomes the quality of the ratio. Definitions that shift between quarters, or exclusions that grow, change the ratio without any change in the business. The six-point checklist for scoring non-GAAP adjustment quality sets out how to evaluate this, and the segment reporting forensic checks cover cases where the unit being measured moves between reported segments.

Customer concentration is a fifth consideration where it applies: a per-customer average is misleading when a few customers dominate revenue. The customer concentration disclosure notes explain how to read those disclosures.

A reproducible case study: Lemonade's Synthetic Agents arithmetic

A unit economics case study is useful only if a reader can reproduce it. Lemonade's Q2 2023 shareholder letter provides one, because it states the assumptions in numbers.

The letter's illustration begins with $100 of CAC, an LTV/CAC ratio of 3 and a 24-month payback period. Under the Synthetic Agents program, the same unit economics apply to $150 of CAC, with cohort repayments expected to take approximately two to three years per cohort. The company also disclosed that the program advances up to 80% of monthly CAC spend with a 16% IRR, and expected the structure to raise the IRR on CAC spend from about 50% to about 90%.

An analyst can test this in four moves:

  1. Restate the unit. With a ratio of 3 on $100 of CAC, the implied lifetime value is $300. With $150 of CAC at the same ratio, it is $450.
  2. Check the financing logic. If 80% of $150 is advanced, the advance is $120 and the company funds $30 itself. The amount to be repaid, and when, depends on the 16% IRR the letter states.
  3. Compare payback with cohort repayment. A 24-month payback and a repayment period of two to three years per cohort are consistent in order of magnitude; a verifier would then ask in later filings whether observed cohort payback matches.
  4. Trace the claim forward. Subsequent quarterly filings and the cost of capital disclosed in them show whether the projected IRR improvement materialized.

The case shows what a well-specified disclosure allows: each figure becomes a hypothesis that later filings confirm or contradict. It also shows the point the letter itself frames: a compelling LTV/CAC ratio can coexist with a payback long enough to make rapid growth capital intensive, so growth pace and cost of capital belong in the same analysis as the ratio.

A second type of case study works at the valuation level. Morgan Stanley's investment management article on customer businesses includes a case study of AT&T Mobility, in which a customer-based analysis suggests a business value of $543 billion, excluding a number of costs. The exclusion is the instructive part: customer-based valuations are sensitive to which costs are left out, so the reproduction exercise must list the omitted costs before the headline figure is compared with anything.

A repeatable verification procedure

The procedure below applies to any filer that reports a unit economics ratio. Where a step is judgment rather than arithmetic, the record of the judgment matters as much as the result.

  1. Collect the claim set. Gather every unit economics statement from earnings slides, shareholder letters, investor day materials and the annual report. Note the document, date and exact wording. Differences between documents are findings.
  2. Define the unit and cohort. Record what is counted, over what period, and whether the figure is observed or projected.
  3. Rebuild the ratio. Recompute from the disclosed inputs, as in the eHealth division above. If inputs are missing, mark the ratio as non-reproducible rather than estimating around the gap.
  4. Bridge to GAAP. Tie the cost pool to reported expense, and check the footnotes and cash flow statement for capitalized contract costs under ASC 340-40.
  5. Search the correspondence. SEC staff comment letters and company responses often reveal what the filer declined to disclose and why, as the Chewy and 2021 examples show.
  6. Track across periods. Compare definitions, cost pools and adjustments quarter over quarter. Stable definitions with improving ratios are stronger evidence than ratios that improve alongside definitional change.
  7. Compare narrative with delivery. Test the management narrative on efficiency, such as the claim that growth is self-funding, against reported cash flow, margins and retention. The sentiment versus performance method and the MD&A tracing workflow describe how to do this with citations.

The result of the procedure is a record, not an opinion: for each claim, a status of reproduced, partially reproduced or not reproducible, with the filing and line that supports the status. Lacuna Index applies this evidence-first logic across covered companies through a consistent, public-records-only process, documented in its methodology walkthrough.

From manual verification to a consistent score

Doing the procedure for one company is manageable. Doing it for a coverage universe, with the same definitions applied to every issuer, is where manual work breaks down: analysts apply thresholds differently, and comparisons across issuers lose meaning. Lacuna Index scores the gap between narrative claims and delivery using only public records such as filings, earnings calls, press releases and proxy statements, with governance logs documenting the scoring.

Free sector benchmarks give the cohort context, with Financials, Insurance, Health Care and other sectors published. Company-level forensic reports, with execution and narrative scores, are available to subscribers through per-company analysis, and the Cohort Pulse and Sector Sweep plans are described on the pricing page.

Lacunaindex

The user guide explains how to read a Lacuna report, and governance teams can pair it with the governance red flags guide.

Our perspective

Unit economics are the most persuasive numbers in a growth company's narrative and the least standardized. No accounting standard defines LTV, so the definition is the disclosure, and the definition is where the gap between claim and delivery usually opens.

Our approach starts from that observation. We do not need insider access to test a ratio; we need the filing, the definition and the arithmetic. When a company discloses its inputs, as eHealth does, the claim can be rebuilt and tracked. When it declines, the refusal is itself a data point about disclosure opacity, and the SEC correspondence records it in the company's own words.

What matters for institutional investors, governance advocates and journalists is consistency. A verified ratio at one issuer is useful; the same test applied with the same rules across a sector is what makes a score comparable and audit-traceable. That is the reason our scoring is built on public records only and published with its governance logs: every conclusion can be followed back to a document and a line.

The practical rule we apply is simple. A unit economics claim that can be reproduced from public evidence earns credit; one that cannot is marked as unverified, and the narrative around it is weighed accordingly.

Glen

FAQ

What is the difference between unit economics and overall profitability?

Unit economics measure the margin on one repeatable unit, before fixed overhead and growth investment. Overall profitability includes all costs. A company can have positive unit economics and a net loss because of fixed costs or deliberate growth spending, so the two answer different questions.

Can LTV/CAC be verified from GAAP financial statements alone?

Not fully. GAAP statements supply revenue, expense and capitalized contract costs, which anchor the cost pool and the revenue side. LTV and CAC themselves are management metrics, so verification relies on supplementary disclosures such as earnings slides and shareholder letters, and on whether the company states inputs and formulas.

Why do SEC staff question LTV/CAC ratios?

When LTV is built from a non-GAAP measure such as cumulative contribution profit, the staff has asked companies to address Item 10(e) of Regulation S-K. Staff have also asked for cohort-specific calculations or removal of the ratio, as in the Chewy and ODDITY correspondence cited above.

Why does payback period matter if LTV/CAC is strong?

Payback measures how long capital is committed before a cohort recovers its acquisition cost. Lemonade's Q2 2023 shareholder letter shows a ratio of 3 alongside a payback of about 24 months, which makes growth capital intensive and ties its pace to the cost of capital.

What should a case study include to be reproducible?

It should state the unit, the cohort, the cost pool, the horizon and the formula, with figures a reader can recompute. The Lemonade illustration works because $100 of CAC, a ratio of 3 and a 24-month payback can each be restated and then checked against later filings.

Sources